The Risks of Being an Executor in New York (And How to Avoid Them)

Executors hold a lot of power during probate, but with that power comes accountability. You’re responsible for everything that happens with the estate—including mistakes.

If the estate includes New York real estate, the stakes are higher. Property is one of the most common ways executors get into trouble — selling below market value, letting taxes or maintenance lapse during a long probate case, or missing a deadline while coordinating with out-of-state heirs. You don’t have to take on that risk alone, and you don’t have to manage it piecemeal either.

Our firm can serve as your attorney, your professional executor, or both — handling the probate case, the estate, and the property sale as one point of contact, so nothing falls through the cracks and nothing lands on you personally.

In this post, we’ll break down what the risks look like, how long they last and what you can do to protect yourself.

What are the risks of being an executor?

1. What can go wrong during probate—what if the executor makes a mistake?
2. As the executor, am I personally liable—are my assets on the line?
3. What happens if estate taxes and debts go unpaid?
4. Are there repercussions for distributing assets to the heirs too early?
5. What if estate investments lose value under the executor’s watch?
6. Family drama: What if you get caught in the middle during probate?
7. What if I live out of state and I’m the executor? What are the risks?
8. How long does all this risk last for executors?
9. Sounds like a lot of risk—maybe I shouldn’t be the executor?
10. How can I protect myself if I’m chosen as executor?

What happens if an executor makes a mistake?

At first, being an executor might sound like a simple administrative job. In reality, it can be stressful, time-consuming and just plain difficult. The probate process typically takes a year or more, and during that time, you’ll be juggling legal paperwork, court deadlines, tax filings, financial management and more—all under the scrutiny of heirs and the court.

With so many moving parts, mistakes can easily happen. The consequences range from minor headaches to major financial repercussions:

• Losing your executor’s commission. This is the compensation you’d normally receive for your work.
• Lawsuits from heirs. If the beneficiaries believe you mishandled something, they can take you to court.
• Personal liability. In the worst-case scenario, your own money or property could be at risk.

Can an executor be sued by beneficiaries?

Yes. Beneficiaries absolutely can—and do—sue executors. For example: if they believe you sold an asset for too little, created delays in the process or treated an heir unfairly. Even if you did nothing wrong, a lawsuit will still cost you time, money and peace of mind. That’s why professional executors take every step possible to reduce the risk of getting sued.

Is there personal liability for an executor?

Yes. Executors can be personally liable for debts, taxes and anything that goes wrong with the estate.

When you become an executor, you’re taking on the legal responsibility to handle the estate correctly. That means paying debts and taxes, filing required returns and distributing assets according to the will and the law. If anything is overlooked—even just by accident—you can be held personally responsible.

Can an executor lose money personally?

Unfortunately, yes. In the worst-case scenario, the executor CAN lose their own money or assets.

For example, let’s say the court determines you made an error that cost the estate money. You could lose your executor’s commission or even have to pay out of your personal funds. That means your bank account, your retirement savings, your kids’ college fund or even your house could be on the line.

Are executors liable for unpaid debts?

Yes and no. If probate is done correctly, the executor is not liable for unpaid debts, and creditors can only seek repayment from the deceased person’s estate (not the executor personally). In other words, just because you’re serving as executor for your best friend or your brother, that doesn’t necessarily make you responsible for their debts.

However, problems can come up if the executor fails to identify or pay a legitimate debt. If you overlook a “knowable” debt (meaning one you could have taken steps to verify), you could be held personally liable for that debt.

What are the executor risks with taxes?

Taxes are one of the most common (and scariest) examples of personal liability. The IRS and state tax departments pay close attention to estate filings because they’re often the last chance to collect what’s owed. If an executor fails to file a return or pay estate taxes properly, the taxing authorities can hold the executor personally responsible.

What if an executor distributes assets too early?

This mistake can be extremely costly.

If you distribute assets to heirs before ensuring all the debts, expenses and taxes are paid, and it later turns out the estate still owes money, you may have to cover those payments out of your own pocket.

Even worse, imagine if the heirs have already spent their inheritance, and they’re not returning your phone calls. Guess who’s legally responsible? You.

The lesson: don’t distribute assets until you are 100% sure every debt and tax has been identified and paid and you have court clearance to close the estate.

Can executors be liable for investment losses?

Yes, and this is a risk that often gets overlooked. Executors are responsible for preserving the value of estate assets. If you hold onto investments that decline in value, or sell property below market price, the heirs may claim that you mismanaged the estate.

For example, let’s say you sell the deceased’s home for $400,000, but the heirs say it could have sold for $450,000. They may demand the $50,000 difference from your commission—or from you personally.

As executor, your #1 goal is to preserve principal, not grow it. That’s why you always want to convert investments to cash as early as possible, even if it means missing out on some interest or dividends during a long probate process. And for most estates, the small return you might earn isn’t worth the extra cost and hassle of hiring a CPA to file a 1041 (the tax form required for estates that earn income).

What are the risks to the executor in probate disputes?

The most common probate disputes have to do with the validity of the will and who’s legally entitled to inherit. One heir might challenge another heir’s right to inherit—for example, an estranged (but still legally married) spouse, or a child from outside of the deceased’s marriage. These situations can get complicated fast.

The bottom line: if you, as the executor, distribute assets before these disputes are fully resolved, you could be personally liable for any resulting errors. Even if the conflict never makes it to court, getting caught in the middle of family drama can create a major headache—and significantly slow down probate.

What are the risks of being an executor in another state?

If you’re serving as executor in another state, that adds an extra layer of complexity. You may not be familiar with local laws and customs, and you might be managing assets that are hundreds of miles away.

Distance can create delays (for example, waiting to access bank accounts or sell property). And those delays can increase your risk of personal liability. If frustrated heirs feel like you’re mismanaging the process and they’re getting shortchanged on their inheritance, it could increase your risk of getting sued.

That’s why getting professional help from a local expert isn’t just helpful—it’s pretty much essential when you’re serving as an out-of-state executor.

How long do executor risks last?

Technically…forever!

There are some limits, but practically any aggressive lawsuit can get around those limits

Many states have laws that give creditors seven months (or a similar time limit) to submit verified claims. There’s a specific legal procedure to become an official creditor, otherwise the executor should not be personally liable for that debt. However, even in the absence of a formal claim, the executor can be held to have constructively known about the debt—or even should have known!

The best practice when closing an estate is to ask heirs to sign a receipt and release, which says the heirs accept their check as the full and final settlement and agree not to sue the executor later. Theoretically, the release is iron-clad protection for the executor. But practically, the heirs can get around it. An heir could claim that she signed the receipt and release because the executor failed to disclose information, otherwise she wouldn’t have signed it, etc.

Should I decline being an executor due to risks?

First off, it’s completely fine to say no to being an executor—and sometimes, it’s the smartest choice.

Every situation is different, so before you decide, you’ll want to weigh a few key factors:

• Complexity of the estate: Are there high-risk assets involved? (Ex: volatile stocks, complicated real estate, tricky tenant situations, small businesses, collectibles, etc.)
• Family dynamics: Are the heirs likely to get along, or are you already seeing signs that family drama could be brewing?
• Geography: How far away did the deceased live from you? Is it worth your time, effort and possible travel expenses to learn the local laws and manage your duties from out-of-state?
• Your experience: Have you ever handled probate before? How confident are you in your ability to navigate the process?

If you have the right experience to offset any of the potential risks, then you’re probably fine taking on the executor role. If not, hiring a professional may be the safer choice.

To understand the difference, let’s look at two situations.

Scenario A: Jenny’s father, Robert, appointed her as executor. She lives in the same city as Robert and is very familiar with his assets and will. While Jenny has a difficult relationship with one out-of-state sibling, she feels confident that her knowledge and proximity will ultimately help her manage her father’s estate successfully. Jenny decides to accept the executor role.

Scenario B: Nick was surprised to learn that his Uncle Charlie named him executor. Nick barely knew Charlie and lives across the country. Charlie’s heirs include multiple nieces and nephews who don’t get along, and one still lives in a rental property Charlie owned. Nick doesn’t feel confident managing this complex estate, so he decides to hire a professional executor.

How to avoid risks as an executor?

If the risks feel like too much, you can always bring in a professional executor to take over.

There’s no shame in declining. In fact, even experienced probate attorneys often decline the executor role because they understand the risks.

Professional executors like myself understand the risks too, but we also know how to take steps to identify and minimize risk—and that gives us confidence that we can serve you effectively.

If you do accept the role, you’ll want to take these steps (at a bare minimum) to minimize your risk:

1. Document everything. Keep records of every transaction, communication and decision.
2. Convert assets to cash ASAP. This minimizes the risk of the assets losing their value and the heirs putting the blame on you.
3. Don’t distribute assets too early. Wait until all debts and taxes have been paid—and be sure to get tax clearance from the IRS and state authorities.
4. Do a full accounting with receipt and releases. When closing the estate, use the court-approved accounting format. That provides full disclosure to the heirs and gives heirs/creditors less wiggle room to argue that you failed to inform them.

And remember—the best way to avoid risk altogether is to hire a pro who can handle all the executor responsibilities for you.

Or call 212-401-2990